The Uninvited Teammate: Imposter Syndrome on the Mountain
by Annie Mueller, PhD
Clinical Psychologist
In 2019, I embarked on a three-day guided Rainier climb. On the first day, the guides asked us to introduce ourselves and share any relevant mountain climbing experience. When it was my turn, I was eager to turn the attention to the next person in the group. I mentioned that I was a trail runner and quickly said that I lacked mountaineering experience.
But this was a bald-faced lie. While it was true that I had never traversed glaciated terrain before, I had spent the last 10 years hiking, backpacking, and running up and down every mountain I could find. Despite having spent months training for the Rainier climb, the word mountaineering triggered a cascade of self-doubt.
This phenomenon has a name: imposter syndrome. Common in high-achieving people, imposter syndrome shows up as persistent self-doubts and fear of being shown as a fraud, despite objective evidence to the contrary. Paradoxically, perfectionists are especially vulnerable to imposter syndrome regardless of their tendency to overprepare and overwork. As mountaineers tend to be high-achieving, goal-oriented perfectionists, it’s fair to say that most people on the mountain struggle with at least some degree of imposter syndrome.
Women and/or individuals who are BIPOC may be especially prone to imposter syndrome in the outdoors, as mountain sports have historically been dominated by white men. Underrepresentation has a tendency to shine a spotlight on pre-existing self-doubts, and reinforces beliefs of not belonging. The research on gender differences is mixed; some studies indicate that imposter syndrome occurs more frequently in women, while others have not found any significant difference between men and women (Bravata et al., 2019).
How Imposter Syndrome Manifests
Whether during training or on the mountain, imposter syndrome can show up in the following ways:
- Feeling like a phony
- Negative self-talk
- Worries that are hard to control
- Feeling undeserving of success
- Being reluctant to ask questions for fear that you might be perceived as unprepared
- Reassurance seeking
- Fear of being the slowest one in the group or falling into comparison traps
- Downplaying your individual role in the trip’s success (“the weather was easy,” “the team pretty much dragged me up”)
If you found yourself nodding along while reading this list, you’re in good company.
Coping with Imposter Syndrome
While fully eliminating imposter syndrome may not be possible, there are many tools for mitigating the impact it may have on your training and climb.
Expect or even welcome it. In my experience, imposter syndrome tends to flare up when I’ve taken steps outside my comfort zone or at times where my success has been highlighted. At the same time, growth is a core value of mine – and I consistently put myself in new situations (on and off the mountain) as a means of living a values-aligned life. To that end, imposter syndrome is inevitable, as unpleasant as it may be.
Shifting the stance from dreading or fighting imposter syndrome to expecting or even welcoming it also changes our relationship to it. Instead of seeing imposter syndrome as a personal failing or an indicator of the absolute truth, can we view it as an unpleasant passerby? Perhaps imposter syndrome is just an unruly guest that pops in when something is new, challenging, or different. If we can simply let it be, we might find that it leaves just as quickly as it came.
Defuse from thoughts. Thought defusion means seeing our thoughts for what they are – they are merely just thoughts, not the literal truth. Our minds have infinite creative ways of telling us that we suck, and these thoughts can be distracting, distressing, and all-consuming. When we are fused with thoughts, we accept them as facts and act accordingly. Defusing means that we pause, take a step back, and decide how we respond.
There are several strategies for practicing thought defusion:
- Assign a voice to the inner self-critic, ideally a TV or movie character (my personal favorite is Debbie Downer from SNL). Something silly works well here.
- Visualize thoughts passing by like clouds in the sky or leaves on a stream.
- Sing the imposter syndrome thoughts as if they were lyrics in an upbeat or silly song, such as “Happy Birthday.”
- Switch up the language. Instead of telling yourself, “I’m not good enough,” say, “I am noticing the thought of not being good enough.”
Practice self-compassion. Everything that we struggle with in daily life tends to rear its ugly head on the mountain. If we struggle with feelings of inadequacy or insecurity in everyday life, those feelings will inevitably work their way into the climb.
The flip side to this means that if we practice self-compassion day-to-day, we give ourselves a better shot at meeting our most difficult moments with understanding and kindness rather than criticism and cruelty. Each time we catch ourselves engaging in harsh self-talk and choose a kinder voice instead, we are practicing for tough moments on the mountain when imposter syndrome flares up.
A simple way to engage self-compassion is to ask yourself what you would tell a friend if they were in the same situation. Odds are, you would never speak to them in the same way as your internal voice. Self-compassion is a universally difficult part of being human. Practice, and practice again.
Act “as if.” In other words, fake it until you make it. Acting “as if” means behaving like the person you want to be instead of waiting for the feeling to appear first. If your goal is to climb mountains with confidence, you might wait a long time for confidence to spontaneously appear – and never end up climbing mountains. Confidence is an emotion that comes from repeated action.
To put this into practice, first identify specific behaviors that a confident mountain climber does. Be as detailed as possible. Then, put these behaviors into action. For example, a confident mountain climber might ensure they are attending to their nutrition and hydration on a climb to prevent bonking, or focus solely on the section of the route immediately ahead of them without catastrophizing about what’s next. The key here to keep in mind is that feelings follow action, not the other way around. To keep this from feeling overwhelming, focus on micro-actions (the smaller the better!).
Climb On
While imposter syndrome is ubiquitous in the high country, the irony is that actual imposters do not lie awake at night worrying if they are good enough. Mountaineers may be especially prone to imposter syndrome, as they tend to be high-achieving perfectionists.
And despite what your mind tells you – if you climb mountains, you are a mountaineer.
Although imposter syndrome thoughts can be uncomfortable and distracting, they do not need to ruin the experience. It may rope itself in as an uninvited teammate, but the climb continues either way. Just be sure to bring Nerds gummy clusters for two.
About the Author
Dr. Annie Mueller is a licensed clinical psychologist who works with outdoor athletes navigating the mental and emotional demands of injury, trauma, grief and loss, identity shifts, and performance-related stress. Her clinical work also addresses anxiety, depression, health and aging-related changes, and the complex transitions that come with time away from—or changes in—the mountains. Learn more about her work at summerlandpsych.com or follow and along on Instagram @summerlandpsych.
References
Bravata et al. (2019). Prevalence, Predictors, and Treatment of Imposter Syndrome: A Systematic Review. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 35, 1252-1275. doi: 10.1007/s11606-019-05364-1